• Cookies Policy
  • ASAI and Remote Working
  • Links
  • Publications
Ph: (01) 6137040 // Email: standards@asai.ie
linkedin
twitter
  • Welcome
  • Make a complaint
    • Advertisement or Promotion
    • Online Behavioural Avertising
  • About ASAI
  • Advertising & Self Regulation
  • ASAI Code
  • Complaints Bulletins
  • News

Heath & Beauty

June 08, 2020
by Seona Parker
Comments are off

Print This Post Print This Post
Bulletin: 20/3
Batch: 262
Reference: 35446
Product: Health & Beauty
Advertiser: Marian Nurseries
Influencer:
Agency:
Medium: Press
Codes:
ASAI Code 7th Edition: 2.4(c), 4.1, 4.4, 11.1, 11.5, 11.6, 11.10

  • Advertisement
  • Complaint
  • Response
  • Conclusion
  • A press advertisement that appeared in a national newspaper stated:
    “I (name redacted) of Marian Nurseries, Lusk have discovered the potential benefits of
    rose bushes cultivated and grown at our facility for the cure of cold/flu. I believe that
    these benefits may also be effective in self-protection from the reported effects of COVID-
    19, by keeping the plant close to the patient. I attribute the recovery of my own colds, flu
    & chest infections to these rose bushes. Available at Marian Nurseries.”

  • The complainant, who considered that the advertising was misleading, said that there
    was no medical evidence to support the claims that the roses grown at the nursery were a
    cure for colds & flu or that they might be an effective protection from COVID-19. They considered that the advertising could entice people with genuine concerns about COVID-19 into buying a product.

  • The advertiser stated that they could see how the claim for their microorganism (an
    entophyte(1)) was hard to believe and that they had found it hard to believe themselves.
    They believed, however, that their experience and the beneficial experience of others that
    had used it, pointed to a very beneficial organism. They provided a list of some
    experiences of cures as evidence:
    - The advertiser’s own colds – a cold that always took antibiotics as it always caused a chest infection and diarrhoea. In this case, their cold was a 3-day event, with no need for medicine and they could work without discomfort.
    - Another case had 2 colds and had the same experience.
    - The advertiser had athletes’ foot which they always had to cure with liniment of iodine, however, this time no treatment was needed and it only lasted 4 days with no itch.
    - The advertiser said that they had a blood test showed they had type 2 diabetes. Their next blood test showed that they were clear. They said that this was documented online under Endophytes which also says that it is in its infancy as it is being tested.

    The advertiser contended that 90% of the organisms in human bodies could not be
    identified but it was known what each organism does. They said that a cold cure has never
    been found but this organism (the endophyte) seemed to work. They referred to articles
    that they had written that they hoped would provide more details. (The articles outlined
    their experience, including that their roses had been free of various common pests and
    problems).

    The advertiser provided a statement that outlined the reasons why they believed their rose
    bushes were effective stating that as the cold was related to Covid19, they believed it was
    reasonable to assume that there was a strong likelihood that the endophyte would have the
    same effect on it. They said that they were attempting to have their product trialled but
    were experiencing difficulties.

    The advertiser stated that when selling their rose bushes, they explained to customers that
    the bushes were fully refundable if the customer was not satisfied.

    The advertiser also stated that they explained to their customers that this was experimental.
    They said that they asked their customers to report their experience so that they could build
    up evidence as it cannot be cultured in laboratories and they would preferably want to trial
    their product on willing patients.

    Footnote: (1) A plant, especially a fungus, which lives inside another plant (source:
    https://www.lexico.com/en/definition/endophyte)

  • Complaint Upheld.

    The Complaints Committee considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’
    response.

    The Committee noted the Code requirements that compliance with the Code is assessed in
    the light of a marketing communication’s probable effect when taken as a whole and in
    context (2.4c) and that claims about health and beauty products and treatments should be
    backed by substantiation, including where relevant, the results of robust and reputable
    trials on human subjects, of sufficient rigour, design and execution as to warrant general
    acceptance of the results. (11.1).

    While the advertisement had referred to “potential benefits” of the product (the rose
    bushes) and had included statements such as “may also be effective”, implying that the
    benefits were not guaranteed, the Committee considered that the impression created by
    the advertisement was that proximity to the rose bushes was an effective treatment for
    Covid-19. The Committee noted that anecdotal evidence did not constitute independent,
    peer reviewed data.

    The Committee considered that the advertising was likely to mislead consumers, including
    those concerned about the impact of COVID-19.

    In the circumstances the Committee considered that the advertising was in breach of
    Sections 4.1. 4.4 and 11.1 of the Code.

    Action Required:
    The advertisement must not reappear in its current form.
    The Complaints Committee told the advertiser not to make claims that were not currently
    appropriately substantiated.

Social Share

    Complaints Bulletins

    • Complaints Bulletins
      • 22/4
      • 22/3
      • 22/2
      • 22/1
      • 21/5
      • 21/4
      • 21/3
      • 21/2
      • 21/1
      • 20/6
      • 20/5
      • 20/4
      • 20/3
      • 20/2
      • 20/1
      • 19/6
      • 19/5
      • 19/4
      • 19/3
      • 19/2
      • 19/1
      • 18/5
      • 18/4
      • 18/3
      • 18/2
      • 18/1
      • 17/5
      • 17/4
      • 17/3
      • 17/2
      • 17/1
      • 16/7
      • 16/6
      • 16/5
      • 16/4
      • 16/3
      • 16/2
      • 16/1
      • 15/6
      • 15/5
      • 15/4
      • 15/3
      • 15/2
      • 15/1
      • 14/8
      • 14/7
      • 14/6
      • 14/5

    Search:


    Filter by:

    Reset

    ©ASAI 2021 // 7 Herbert Street, Dublin 2, D02 K838 // Ph: (01) 6137040
    website by smudge design
    /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - start */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - end */ /* ----------------------------------------- */
    This website uses cookies to improve your browsing and interactive experience. If you are happy to proceed with this, please click Accept

    If you wish read more about our cookie policy please Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT