• Cookies Policy
  • ASAI and Remote Working
  • Links
  • Publications
Ph: (01) 6137040 // Email: standards@asai.ie
linkedin
twitter
  • Welcome
  • Make a complaint
    • Advertisement or Promotion
    • Online Behavioural Avertising
  • About ASAI
  • Advertising & Self Regulation
  • ASAI Code
  • Complaints Bulletins
  • News

Health & Beauty (Alternative Therapies)

June 09, 2021
by Seona Parker
Comments are off

Print This Post Print This Post
Bulletin: 21/4
Batch: 273
Reference: 25269
Product: Health & Beauty (Alternative Therapies)
Advertiser: Lidl
Influencer:
Agency:
Medium: Online - Company Website
Codes:
ASAI Code 7th Edition: 2.4(c), 3.3, 4.1, 4.4, 4.9, 4.10, 11.1

  • Advertisement
  • Complaint
  • Response
  • Conclusion
  • The advertisement on the Special Offers section of Lidl’s website for an illuminated salt crystal bowl featured an image of the product and referred to the following:

    “Happy & Healthy Illuminated Salt Crystal Bowl – Melinera €19.99.

    Handcrafted from solid salt crystal. Base made from acacia wood with 4 salt crystal massage spheres. Massage your hands, feet, neck or back with the warmed spheres.

    Benefits:
    • Cleanses the air easing allergies & coughing
    • Increases energy levels
    • Improves sleep, mood & concentration
    • Environmentally friendly light source”

  • Issue 1
    The complainant referred to the advertised benefits indicated for the product and challenged whether the advertisers held substantiation for the claims outlined.

    Issue 2
    The complainant challenged whether the light source referenced was an “environmentally friendly light source”. He considered that as the light was said to warm the salt spheres, it could not be an LED source, which would minimise power consumption.

  • Issue 1
    The advertisers said that their advertisement had advertised certain claims for the Melinera Crystal Salt Bowl, namely its potential to increase air quality, relieve congestion, improve sleep, improve energy levels and overall mood. They said that these claims were supported by a number of scientific studies and commonly advertised uses for Himalayan Salt Lamps. They referred to two studies, one in relation to the positive health benefits of negative ions (1) and a second in relation to the effect of blue light on sleep (2). The advertisers did not indicate where the substantiation for the advertising claims were in the referenced studies.

    The advertisers said that their claims had, therefore, not been made in the absence of substantiation or supporting evidence and although the claims may have a basis in homeopathy or other mainstream disciples, this did not necessarily undervalue the assertions made in relation to the lamp’s common uses.

    Issue 2
    The advertisers said that the environmentally friendly light source housed within the salt lamp consisted of E14 (3), W15 lightbulbs, which had a relatively low energy output in comparison to Standard E14 lightbulbs typically sold.

    Further information:
    The ASAI Executive were advised by Codema (4) that a 15W bulb would consume less energy than a 40W or 60W bulb but it would not be considered a low energy bulb in the same way as an LED or CFL bulb was.

    FOOTNOTES:
    (1)The Positive Health Benefits of Negative Ions, Nutritional Review, Jim English, April 22, 2013-https://nutritionreview.org/2013/04/positive-health-benefits-negative-ions/
    (2) Blue Light has a Dark Side: What is Blue Light? The effect blue light has on your sleep and more, Harvard Health Publishing, Harvard Medical School, May 2012
    (3) This bulb cap is widely used in low wattage bulbs e.g., candle lamps R50 reflectors. Source: Guide_to_Energy_Saving_Lightbulbs_Buildsmart.pdf (codema.ie)
    (4) Codema is Dublin's Energy Agency and aims to accelerate Dublin’s low-carbon transition in order to mitigate the effects of climate change and improve the lives of citizens.

  • The Complaints Committee considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’ response.

    Issue 1 – Upheld
    The Complaints Committee noted the studies referenced by the advertisers and that information had not been received to show how the studies were relevant to the advertising claims. Without the required substantiation for the claims made, the Committee concluded that the advertising was in breach of Sections, 4.9 and 11.1 of the Code.

    Issue 2 - Upheld
    The Complaints Committee noted that the light source housed within the salt lamp was provided by E14, W15 lightbulbs. They also noted, however, that the advertisement had stated that one of the benefits of the product was that it had an “environmentally friendly light source” and not that the bulbs used were relatively low energy. As the claim in relation to the product having an environmentally friendly light source, which the Committee considered was an absolute claim, had not been substantiated, the Committee concluded that the advertisement was in breach of Section 4.9 of the Code.

    ACTION REQUIRED:
    The advertising should not appear in the same format again unless substantiation is available for the claims made.

Social Share

    Complaints Bulletins

    • Complaints Bulletins
      • 23/1
      • 22/4
      • 22/3
      • 22/2
      • 22/1
      • 21/5
      • 21/4
      • 21/3
      • 21/2
      • 21/1
      • 20/6
      • 20/5
      • 20/4
      • 20/3
      • 20/2
      • 20/1
      • 19/6
      • 19/5
      • 19/4
      • 19/3
      • 19/2
      • 19/1
      • 18/5
      • 18/4
      • 18/3
      • 18/2
      • 18/1
      • 17/5
      • 17/4
      • 17/3
      • 17/2
      • 17/1
      • 16/7
      • 16/6
      • 16/5
      • 16/4
      • 16/3
      • 16/2
      • 16/1
      • 15/6
      • 15/5
      • 15/4
      • 15/3
      • 15/2
      • 15/1
      • 14/8
      • 14/7
      • 14/6
      • 14/5

    Search:


    Filter by:

    Reset

    ©ASAI 2021 // 7 Herbert Street, Dublin 2, D02 K838 // Ph: (01) 6137040
    website by smudge design
    /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - start */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - end */ /* ----------------------------------------- */
    This website uses cookies to improve your browsing and interactive experience. If you are happy to proceed with this, please click Accept

    If you wish read more about our cookie policy please Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT