• Cookies Policy
  • ASAI and Remote Working
  • Links
  • Publications
Ph: (01) 6137040 // Email: standards@asai.ie
linkedin
twitter
  • Welcome
  • Make a complaint
    • Advertisement or Promotion
    • Online Behavioural Avertising
  • About ASAI
  • Advertising & Self Regulation
  • ASAI Code
  • Complaints Bulletins
  • News

Motoring

April 19, 2016
by Geraldine Scanlan
Comments are off

Print This Post Print This Post
Bulletin: 16/2
Batch: 233
Reference: 24584
Product: Motoring
Advertiser: Meridian Motors Limited
Influencer:
Agency:
Medium: Internet (Company Website)
Codes:ASAI Code 6th Edition: 1.6(c), 2.22, 2.24, 2.41, 2.42

  • Advertisement
  • Complaint
  • Response
  • Conclusion
  • Two advertisements on the advertisers’ website referred to the following:

    The first advertisement for a 2014 BMW X5 offered the following information:

    “Make: BMW
    Model: X5
    Year: 2014
    Price: €61,000…”

    Under the heading “Additional Information” an in-depth description of the car was provided.

    The second advertisement for a 2014 BMW X5 offered the following information:

    “Make: BMW
    Model: X5
    Year: 2014
    Price: €67,500…”

    Once again under the heading “Additional Information” an in-depth description of the car was provided.

  • The complainants in both cases were informed that they would have to add 23% VAT to the price as it was not included in the advertised price. The complainants considered both advertisements to be misleading.

  • The advertisers said that they sold commercial and non-commercial registered vehicles to their large client base and had been doing so successfully for over 10 years. They said that in relation to the vehicles mentioned by the complainants their client base could have been:

    • Commercial businesses that purchase vehicles for business use.
    • Commercial businesses that purchase vehicles for the use of directors/staff (commercially purchased, privately taxed).
    • Private individuals.

    The advertisers said that the vehicles in question could have been sold to any of the three groups mentioned above. Had a business/sole trader/VAT registered entity wished to purchase the vehicle referenced in the first advertisement it would have cost them €61,000. To a private individual, with no VAT number, the cost would be €61,000+VAT.

    They considered that in this case when the price of the vehicle was being loaded onto the website it should have referenced the fact that the cost was €61,000+VAT, since receiving the complaint the text on the website had been amended to reflect the fact that VAT was applicable to the price.

    Further Information:
    The Secretariat pointed out to the advertisers that Section 2.42 of the Code referred to the fact that “Except in marketing communications addressed primarily to the trade, prices quoted should normally include VAT and other taxes, duties or inescapable costs to the consumer.” It was not acceptable to advertise a vehicle to a consumer without including the cost of the VAT in the overall price.

    The advertisers said that Section 2.42 of the Code did not allow the level of flexibility they needed and were they to enforce it in a narrow manner this would impact on their ability to attract business.

    The Secretariat pointed out to the advertisers that the Code had been in existence for over 30 years and that Section 2.42 had never given rise to any significant concerns. They suggested to the advertisers that they quote both the VAT exclusive price – clearly stating that it was VAT exclusive and the VAT inclusive price - stating that it was VAT inclusive.

  • Complaints Upheld.

    The Complaints Committee considered the details of the complaints and the advertisers’ response. The Committee considered that unless advertising was directed primarily to the trade, prices should be quoted on a VAT-inclusive basis. Where the advertising was directed to a mixed audience, as indicated by the advertisers, they could also if they wished give the VAT-exclusive price, provided it was clear that it was VAT-exclusive, and provided that the VAT-inclusive price was the more prominently stated price.

    The Committee considered that the advertising was in breach of Sections 2.22, 2.24 and 2.42 of the Code.

    Action Required:
    The advertising should be amended in accordance with the advice indicated above in compliance with Section 2.42 of the Code.

Social Share

    Complaints Bulletins

    • Complaints Bulletins
      • 22/4
      • 22/3
      • 22/2
      • 22/1
      • 21/5
      • 21/4
      • 21/3
      • 21/2
      • 21/1
      • 20/6
      • 20/5
      • 20/4
      • 20/3
      • 20/2
      • 20/1
      • 19/6
      • 19/5
      • 19/4
      • 19/3
      • 19/2
      • 19/1
      • 18/5
      • 18/4
      • 18/3
      • 18/2
      • 18/1
      • 17/5
      • 17/4
      • 17/3
      • 17/2
      • 17/1
      • 16/7
      • 16/6
      • 16/5
      • 16/4
      • 16/3
      • 16/2
      • 16/1
      • 15/6
      • 15/5
      • 15/4
      • 15/3
      • 15/2
      • 15/1
      • 14/8
      • 14/7
      • 14/6
      • 14/5

    Search:


    Filter by:

    Reset

    ©ASAI 2021 // 7 Herbert Street, Dublin 2, D02 K838 // Ph: (01) 6137040
    website by smudge design
    /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - start */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - end */ /* ----------------------------------------- */
    This website uses cookies to improve your browsing and interactive experience. If you are happy to proceed with this, please click Accept

    If you wish read more about our cookie policy please Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT