• Cookies Policy
  • ASAI and Remote Working
  • Links
  • Publications
Ph: (01) 6137040 // Email: standards@asai.ie
linkedin
twitter
  • Welcome
  • Make a complaint
    • Advertisement or Promotion
    • Online Behavioural Avertising
  • About ASAI
  • Advertising & Self Regulation
  • ASAI Code
  • Complaints Bulletins
  • News

Motoring

September 22, 2015
by Mary Gisbey
Comments are off

Print This Post Print This Post
Bulletin: 15/4
Batch: 229
Reference: 24535
Product: Volkswagen Up
Advertiser: Volkswagen Group Ireland Ltd
Influencer:
Agency:
Medium: Television
Codes:ASAI Code 6th Edition: 1.6(c), 2.28, 2.52

  • Advertisement
  • Complaint
  • Response
  • Conclusion
  • The television advertisement was set in an eye clinic. The sign behind the reception
    desk in the clinic read “The Laser Eye Clinic”. The opening scene featured the receptionist
    speaking to a female prospective client about the various types of laser eye surgery available.
    Through a glass window in the background an eye surgeon can be seen testing his laser operating
    equipment. We see the surgeon blowing into the equipment, the laser fires at the wall and a picture
    falls down. We see a male patient sitting on a trolley in the operating room with two people
    wearing scrubs. The male patient leaves the room and speaks to another person in scrubs he tells
    them “it feels really good.”

    While all the above ensued the conversation between the receptionist and prospective client took
    place as follows:

    Receptionist: “Machine wise you’ve two options. The Xtron laser 8000 one of only three in the
    country. Or the laser IV one perhaps not as new but the treatment is a lot cheaper. A few problems
    in its old age” (This is the one which fired on its own knocking the picture from the wall).

    Client: “Haven’t we all. Best go with the old faithful then.” (Referring to the older equipment).

    The woman is then shown lying on the trolley with her head strapped into place as the she waits for
    the procedure to begin. She looks out the window and sees the earlier male patient walking towards
    a red Volkswagen. The final screen shows the Volkswagen logo accompanied by the following on-screen
    text:
    “You get what you pay for up!
    Up! from €8,635 Well worth it Das Auto.”

  • The complainant considered it inappropriate to compare laser eye surgery to purchasing a car. She said that there were many people waiting to have corrective laser surgery and advertising such as this, portraying cheap surgery equipment, did little to help these people or alleviate their fears if they were frightened or worried about having the procedure.

  • The advertisers said that the tone of the advertisement was very much tongue in cheek and the scenario depicted was one that would not occur in reality. The concept behind their advertisement was that ‘You get so much more with Volkswagen’ because they do not cut corners. They said to illustrate this they had used a very inept looking optician using a very old piece of equipment resembling a pneumatic drill that would have looked more in place on a building site.

    They considered the scenario used to be fictitious, humorous, and so unbelievable that
    it would not cause fear or distress.

    The advertisers also said that it had never been their intention to discredit another business or
    product, they considered it highly unlikely that an eye clinic existed where a pneumatic drill like
    laser would be used to carry out a sensitive eye procedure. They reiterated once again that it had
    never been their intention to cause fear or distress with
    their marketing communication.

  • The Complaints Committee considered the details of the complaint and the advertisers’ response. While accepting that some consumers may be nervous of having laser eye surgery, they considered that the scene portrayed in the advertisement was far-fetched and could not be likened to the normal surrounds of a laser eye clinic. In the circumstances the Committee did not consider that any breach of the Code had occurred and did not uphold the complaint.

    Action Required:
    No further action was required in this case.

Social Share

    Complaints Bulletins

    • Complaints Bulletins
      • 22/4
      • 22/3
      • 22/2
      • 22/1
      • 21/5
      • 21/4
      • 21/3
      • 21/2
      • 21/1
      • 20/6
      • 20/5
      • 20/4
      • 20/3
      • 20/2
      • 20/1
      • 19/6
      • 19/5
      • 19/4
      • 19/3
      • 19/2
      • 19/1
      • 18/5
      • 18/4
      • 18/3
      • 18/2
      • 18/1
      • 17/5
      • 17/4
      • 17/3
      • 17/2
      • 17/1
      • 16/7
      • 16/6
      • 16/5
      • 16/4
      • 16/3
      • 16/2
      • 16/1
      • 15/6
      • 15/5
      • 15/4
      • 15/3
      • 15/2
      • 15/1
      • 14/8
      • 14/7
      • 14/6
      • 14/5

    Search:


    Filter by:

    Reset

    ©ASAI 2021 // 7 Herbert Street, Dublin 2, D02 K838 // Ph: (01) 6137040
    website by smudge design
    /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - start */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - end */ /* ----------------------------------------- */
    This website uses cookies to improve your browsing and interactive experience. If you are happy to proceed with this, please click Accept

    If you wish read more about our cookie policy please Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT