• Cookies Policy
  • ASAI and Remote Working
  • Links
  • Publications
Ph: (01) 6137040 // Email: [email protected]
linkedin
twitter
  • Welcome
  • Make a complaint
    • Advertisement or Promotion
    • Online Behavioural Avertising
  • About ASAI
  • Advertising & Self Regulation
  • ASAI Code
  • Complaints Bulletins
  • News

Telecommunications (Mobile Broadband)

June 22, 2017
by mveale
Comments are off

Print This Post Print This Post
Bulletin: 17/3
Batch: 242
Reference: 26662
Product: Telecommunications (Mobile Broadband)
Advertiser: Three Ireland (Hutchison) Limited
Agency:
Medium: Internet (Company Website)

ASAI Code 7th Edition: 2.4(c), 4.1, 4.9, 4.10, 4.33

  • Advertisement
  • Complaint
  • Response
  • Conclusion
  • Advertising on Three.ie stated “Ireland's leading mobile data network with FREE 4G
    access for life Free 4G for life, for all Three customers. ... Our 4G network is currently
    rolling out across Ireland. To find out if it's in your area, check our coverage map …
    What's more, we're rolling out 4G Plus which offers the fastest speeds available on
    mobile. With 4G Plus Three customers will be able to enjoy peak speeds of 225 Mbps
    for free … As Ireland's leading mobile data network Three are offering 4G Plus to all
    customers with compatible handsets no matter what plan they are on.”

  • Vodafone Ireland objected to the claim that Three were Ireland’s leading mobile data
    network. They said that no substantiation was provided for the claim on Three.ie and
    queried on what basis the claim was made. They said their network had been identified
    by P3(1) as having Ireland’s best in test mobile data network(2), that ComReg’s
    Assessment of Mobile Network Operators’ Compliance with Licence Obligation from
    Winter 2015 showed that Vodafone had the best speeds in the Data Speed in Drive
    Test(3), and that ComReg’s market share report showed that Vodafone had a higher
    market share than three(4).
    Vodafone said that they considered that Three were in breach of Section 4.33 of the
    ASAI Code in relation to their use of the word ‘leading’.

    1 http://www.p3-networkanalytics.com/
    2 http://p3-cert.com/ueber-p3/p3-aktuell/latest_certificates/
    3 https://www.comreg.ie/publication/assessment-of-mobile-network-operatorsa%C2%80%C2%99-compliance-with-licence-obligationscoverage-
    winter-2015/ PAGE 27-28
    4 http://www.comreg.ie/csv/downloads/ComReg1617.pdf PAGE 69-70

  • Three said that their claim was “Ireland’s Leading Mobile Data Network” with an
    express reference on the data element. They said that they took the accuracy of their
    advertising very seriously and aimed at all times to be in strict compliance with the
    Code.
    They noted that Section 4.33 of the Code, which was the provision cited by Vodafone
    in its complaint, did not preclude the use of the word “leading” in advertisements but
    that such claims should be capable of substantiation with market share data or similar
    proof by the party making that claim. They said that their claim was substantiated by
    the fact that Three’s % share of the total “Other Data Vols” as set out in figure 4.3.1 of
    ComReg’s Q4 2015 Quarterly Report(5) was in excess of 50% when the claim was
    initially made and again this was substantiated more recently as per ComReg’s Q1
    2016 publication where the figure was again in excess of 50%. Therefore they carried
    more data than all other mobile networks and mobile service providers (including
    MVNO(6) service providers hosted on the Three network) combined.

    They explained that each service provider was obligated to report usage data to
    ComReg on a quarterly basis. ComReg used this data for its publication. Each service
    provider would be able to calculate their own market share % of the total ‘Other Data
    Vols’ using the data as submitted. As they were over 50% of the total figure, no other
    operator would be able to make this claim or substantiate same.
    Three argued that Vodafone claim to have proof of higher speeds or higher consumer
    market share were not relevant to the point. They considered that it was a matter for
    Three to substantiate the claim it makes (as above) rather than a competitor
    demonstrating the benefits of its product or services by way of rebuttal.
    They said that Three’s mobile data offering was clearly the most popular in the market
    amongst users of mobile data. They rejected any claim that they had contravened the
    ASAI Code.
    Additionally, the advertisers said that neither the metrics presented by Vodafone or
    Three were wrong, they were simply different metrics of comparing mobile data
    performance by operators. They considered therefore that it was incorrect to state that
    advertisements based on any of the ComReg metric was misleading or not
    substantiated.

    5 https://www.comreg.ie/csv/downloads/ComReg1617.pdf
    6 MVNO - mobile virtual network operator is a wireless communications services provider that does not own the wireless
    network infrastructure over which the MVNO provides services to its customers
    (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_virtual_network_operator)

  • Conclusion: Complaint Not Upheld

    The Complaints Committee considered the detail of the complaint and the advertisers’
    response.

    The Committee noted that the Code did not restrict the use of the word ‘leading’ to a
    particular situation. However, the context of the use of the word should not be likely
    to mislead. In this case, they noted that the claim ‘Ireland’s leading mobile data
    network’ contained the qualifier ‘data’. The Committee considered that consumers
    would understand that the claim related solely to ‘data’ rather than to other service
    elements of mobile coverage. In the circumstances they did not consider that the
    advertisement was in breach of the Code.

    ACTION REQUIRED: No further action was required.

Social Share

    Complaints Bulletins

    • Complaints Bulletins
      • 21/2
      • 21/1
      • 20/6
      • 20/5
      • 20/4
      • 20/3
      • 20/2
      • 20/1
      • 19/6
      • 19/5
      • 19/4
      • 19/3
      • 19/2
      • 19/1
      • 18/5
      • 18/4
      • 18/3
      • 18/2
      • 18/1
      • 17/5
      • 17/4
      • 17/3
      • 17/2
      • 17/1
      • 16/7
      • 16/6
      • 16/5
      • 16/4
      • 16/3
      • 16/2
      • 16/1
      • 15/6
      • 15/5
      • 15/4
      • 15/3
      • 15/2
      • 15/1
      • 14/8
      • 14/7
      • 14/6
      • 14/5

    Search:


    Filter by:

    Reset

    ©ASAI 2021 // 7 Herbert Street, Dublin 2, D02 K838 // Ph: (01) 6137040
    website by smudge design
    /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - start */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* ----------------------------------------- */ /* Content Template: Complaint_Content_Type - end */ /* ----------------------------------------- */
    This website uses cookies to improve your browsing and interactive experience. If you are happy to proceed with this, please click Accept

    If you wish read more about our cookie policy please Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.